🚗
The council recommends
On: "Should I buy a new car or a used one?"
Top pick
Buy a 2- to 3-Year-Old Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Car
A late-model CPO vehicle sidesteps the brutal first-wave depreciation while saving you roughly $23,000 compared to average new car transaction prices. You retain manufacturer warranty backing and late-model safety tech without paying the $50,000 new-car premium. Choose new only if you secure near-0% promotional APR and plan to drive the vehicle for over a decade.
Runner-up
Buy brand new only if you secure promotional 0-1.9% financing and intend to keep it 10+ years.
Wildcard
Consider leasing an EV with heavy manufacturer tax credit pass-throughs to avoid depreciation entirely.
Best time
Act now if you find good CPO inventory, or wait for year-end dealer clearance events for new car promos.
95%
aligned
All experts unanimously recommend purchasing a 2-3 year old certified pre-owned vehicle over a new one.
Live context
Gathered Oct 6, 2026, 4:42 PMNew-vehicle average transaction price was $50,089 in August 2026, the first time it crossed $50,000 that year. In June 2026, the new-vehicle ATP was $49,758, up 0.6% year over year; Cox Automotive said price inflation remained below the long-term average. Used-vehicle listing p…
Sources
Your turnFacing a decision like this?Council puts 3 AI models on your question and gives you one verdict. Free, no signup.
Not on this panel
Claude Fable 5.1 and Gemini 3.1 Pro didn't sit on this council.
Council Pro seats the strongest model from every lab.
Where they agree
✓Steep initial depreciation makes new cars at ~$50,000 financially inefficient.
✓A 2-3 year old certified pre-owned (CPO) vehicle offers the ideal balance of value and warranty.
✓Very old, high-mileage budget cars should be avoided due to elevated market prices and repair risk.
Where they diverge
↔How strongly promotional new-car financing rates could sway the decision toward buying new.
↔The acceptable age range for a used vehicle, varying from 2-3 years to up to 4 years old.
↔The degree to which the roughly $23,000 upfront savings outweighs long-term ownership perks.
The 3 takes
GPT-5.6 TerraLens · TCO & Model Reliability
Recommends a 2-4 year old certified pre-owned model from a reliable brand to sidestep steep early depreciation.
78% confident
Claude Sonnet 5.5Lens · Financing & Value Gap
Suggests a 2-3 year old CPO car unless subsidized new financing significantly closes the total cost gap.
68% confident
Gemini 3.8 FlashLens · Upfront Cost & Depreciation
Advocates for a 2-3 year old CPO or inspected used car to capture an upfront discount exceeding $23,000.
82% confident
InstinctJev · TypeSafeCostly to undoMostly personal taste
Instinct said used one (98%). The council agreed.
Related sessions
Take the council with you
Ask, follow up and revisit every verdict from your phone.
Synthesized from 3 independent expert passes. Treat as informed input, not a guarantee. Your own judgment is the final vote.